Icontest 15 - Savvy, Yo ho ho and a bottle of WUT? Options

[Leyviur]

Well you're talking about being 'too picky' in a contest with rules like an iron maiden. It would be just another spike in the torture device.

[Marionette]

Too picky in the wording of the icon is a bit much, to me.
I'm not Feral though, and this isn't my icontest. So I'm just giving my opinion.

[Irysa]

Feral, if we follow your logic of Cierra being the only one of age to drink, surely Lina isn't and we have an UNDERAGE DRINKER ON OUR HANDS?

[Malice]

uh oh noes? ;-;

I like #5.. :[

[Feral Phoenix]

Possibly.

But I dunno, she just looks cute giving the viewer the face and asking why the rum is gone. :D

RuikiaKarine (you like Bleach, don't you...?), you Private Message your votes to me.

Malice, your new blinking icon looks much better than the one you used to have a million years ago. :D

[Irysa]

BUT THATS CHARACTER BASHING, SINCE ITS SAYING LINA IS AN UNDERAGE ALCOHOLIC IF CIERRA'S THE ONLY ONE SOMEHOW LEGAL?

This post has been edited by Chaos Seraph: Oct 4 2006, 03:02 PM

[Feral Phoenix]

I dunno. It doesn't depict Lina drinking alcohol, she's just asking why the rum is gone.

That doesn't necessarily mean she's a drunk. :D

VOTE VOTE VOTE VOTE VOTE!

I don't want this to be another week where only three people vote!

[Malice]

HAY U. I BLAME ELEMENTS 2 >:O

I refuse to vote........

[Feral Phoenix]

Malice, your post makes no sense.

[Irysa]

I dunno. It doesn't depict Lina drinking alcohol, she's just asking why the rum is gone.

That doesn't necessarily mean she's a drunk. :D

So obviously looking for/asking for Rum and getting turned down and being upset doesn't mean she drinks?

[Marionette]

What, exactly, are you going on about?
Both icons are acceptable, there's no need to argue about something like this.

[Feral Phoenix]

HAY U. I BLAME ELEMENTS 2 >:O

I refuse to vote........

OH! PS Elements?

Okay, it makes sense now. XD

But please vote anyway? ;_;~~ As it is, we've got a tie...

[Irysa]

What, exactly, are you going on about?
Both icons are acceptable, there's no need to argue about something like this.

If those are, I don't know why various ones by Ash and Sturm got rejected.

Ash's previous one wasn't attempting to take the piss out of Ledah, it was a joke notifying his only desire to use Lorelei all the time, and I don't quite see how it could be taken as Character bashing. If ( according to what was said before about Cierra being the only one allowed to be pictured drunk * For reasons unbeanownst, one paper shouldn't force that idea * ) Cierra's the only one of legal age according to Feral, then surely if we follow those interpretations, icon number 1 is character bashing as well?

[Marionette]

I don't see the character bashing in this thread. What's legal =/= what's moral. Just because it's illegal for certain places to have minors to drink, doesn't mean it's the same everywhere.

Anyway, there's no assumption (even if there was... who cares?) that Lina drinks, she's just asking where the rum's gone to go with the theme. It's a quote. A quote by Jack Sparrow, you know, the theme? As for past problems with the icontests, take it up directly with Feral in pms or with us if it is a problem.

[Irysa]

I didn't see the character bashing on Sturm or Ash's icons. Just because Feral doesn't like the fact that Ledah did insist on only using Lorelei, and Ash pointed it out, in a humorous manner, doesn't make it have malicious ( spelling? ) intent surely?

Moderators have jobs to do, but aren't they supposed to be impartial?

Also, what if I see the assumption? I honestly couldn't care less if it was, but directly sticking to what she said herself, number 1 doesn't qualify.
As for PMs, this is basically bringing it up surely? Or were you reffering to via PMs again?